10. CONCLUSION

The Conques tympanum therefore ends with an admonition which invites the pilgrim to correct his behavior: O PECCATORES TRANSMUTETIS NISI MORES IUDICIUM DURUM VOBIS SCITOTE FUTURUM (O sinners, unless you reform your morals, know that the future judgment will be harsh for you).

This warning respond to the exhortation in the Acts of the Apostles: “Repent, then, and turn to God, so that your sins may be wiped out, and thus the Lord may bring in the time of respite. He will then send the Messiah who was destined for you, Jesus. Heaven must receive him until the time comes for God to restore everything, as he promised long ago through his holy prophets." (Act 3:19-21)

We find in this extract the concept of universal restoration (i.e. apocatastasis), which Origen defended, as an ideal to achieve. But is this really the theory of the Conques tympanum? Well no ! and it is the gestures of Christ which signify this to us.

A retracted thumb, an uneven wave count and the silence of Tartarus

It is necessary to note a small detail, discreet but full of meaning: the retracted thumb of the left hand of Christ, the one which pours out the Graces of the Lord on Humanity. This withdrawal means that the granting of Grace is neither absolute nor universal.

La rétractation du pouce
The retracted thumb: a restriction in the granting of Grace

 

In Conques, hell is indeed promised to the ungodly and to those who do not repent.
A second detail confirms that it is no matter of apocatastasis here: the waves emanating from Christ are fewer in number on the side of Tartarus than on the side of Paradise.

Un nombre inégal d'ondes
The titulus which supports the floor of the lower register of Tartarus constitutes an exception: it bears no text and remains silent. The last word of the last verse of this sculptural sermon stops in fact right at the gate of hell: beyond there reigns a deafening silence. (1)

The silence of Hell
An eternal Present  

The parousia being "an eternal Present", (2) the tympanum of Conques holds up to us a mirror where we can recognize ourselves, here and now and delivers us a perfectly audible message eight centuries after its creation.
Because what is it talking about, if not about us? It talks to us about Power and Money, War, Homosexuality, Abortion, Good and Evil, the Living and the Dead. About the End of the World which is approaching, but also about Faith and Hope.

Le Frère Régis en plein commentaire

At the end of this approach, the tympanum of Conques - which marks the apogee of the Abbey of Conques - appears above all as an essential step in the history of Art and Civilizations. Far from being a “barbaric” work from a “rude era” as Prosper Mérimée said, (3) this Masterpiece of Romanesque statuary would rather be the Paragon of the Romanesque Renaissance.

 

The Tympanum bears marks of the influence of monastic schools (ancestors of universities), notably that of the abbey of Saint-Victor in Paris where the great pedagogue, theologian and naturalist Hugh of Saint Victor, adept in the dialogue between faith and reason, lays the foundations of a teaching based on knowledge and reasoning. He was an early Humanist. He gave birth to scholasticism drawing its didactic methods, its rhetoric, its hermeneutics, its literary and poetic talents and even its mnemonic devices from the authors of Antiquity. (4)

Une école monastique médiévale
Monastic School


The originality of the Conques tympanum, unique in its kind, is based on its theological paradigm, inherited from Hugues de Saint-Victor, which offers an alternative to Hell, suggesting the intuition of a Purgatory at the end of the process of Restoration of the sinners. It marks a historic stage in the evolution of theological thought about the final ends, even if, nowadays, the dogma of Purgatory is no longer professed in the Roman Church. The fact remains that the Benedictines in Rouergue of the 12th century based their pastoral work on Hope rather than Fear.

(1) Just before this final silence, the last letter of the last word of the tympanum, the M of FUTURUM, takes the form of the symbol of infinity as if to signify the eternal duration of a possible condemnation. (return)

Futurum (return)

(2) According to Iraneus of Lyon (2nd century) (return)

(3"Although the work is barbaric, we can distinguish in its composition, more Art, and I would say more Feling than one would expect from a crude era."   Prosper. Mérimée,  Notes d'un voyage en Auvergne, 1838, Paris, Fournier p. 180.  (return)

(4) The Abbey of Conques attaches particular importance to Blessed Hugh of Saint-Victor, whom we have encountered throughout this study. Moreover, it venerates in its Ecclesiastical Treasury relics of Venerable Hugo. (return)

Previous Page

 

Previous Page

HOME
TYMPANUN THEME
THE PROJECT
STRUCTURE
PARADISE
LIMBO
TARTARUS
THE SINS
THE 4 SENS
LEONINE VERSES
CONCLUSION